Back to archive
Go to main site

Illegal immigration and labour markets

Free Market Foundation

Articles-2
  • This post is an unformatted archive version and will be updated and properly formatted soon.

The Bush Administration in the U.S.A. is considering an amnesty and the granting of permanent resident status to more than a million illegal Mexican immigrants. Michael Barone, author of “The New Americans: How the Melting Pot Can Work Again” (Regnery, 2001), argues for granting such people legal status – including illegal immigrants from countries other than Mexico.

  • An amnesty for illegal immigrants has been part of every major change in the immigration laws since 1965.
  • It is not a good idea to have large numbers of non-citizens living outside the law because it leaves them prey to exploitation, and discourages them from returning home.
  • Stopping “Latino-looking” people is regarded as unacceptable, and Members of the U.S. Congress squelched attempts to require documents from those crossing the U.S.-Canadian border.

    Restrictionism is statist, says Barone. The restrictive laws of 1921 and 1924 followed World War I, in which the government seized the railroads, controlled war production and imprisoned war protestors. The war gave new powers to the state, and restrictionists used them to block immigration.

    Today, America should adjust its immigration laws to the demands of the labour market.

  • Mexican President Vicente Fox has proposed European Union-like open borders, and hopes that economic growth and governmental reform will create jobs and make Mexico more attractive to its citizens.
  • A 1997 Mexican law allows those who become U.S. citizens to remain Mexican citizens (dual citizenship), setting up a benign competition between the two countries for these workers.
  • Mexico’s population growth has slowed sharply, so it will probably not need as many jobs or generate so many immigrants into the U.S. in the future.

    Thus flows of people across the border may eventually reach equilibrium – as with Puerto Rico and the mainland U.S. since 1961.

    Source: Michael Barone (U.S. News & World Report), Markets Dictate Liberalization Of Immigration Law, Wall Street Journal, July 25, 2001.

    For text http://interactive.wsj.com/articles/SB996015306125283790.htm

    FMF\8 August 2001

    • Share

    Fund the FMF

    Help FMF to promote the rule of law, personal liberty, and economic freedom.

    Donate

    For more content like this, Subscribe to FMF

    Picture of Free Market Foundation

    Free Market Foundation

    General queries: FMF@fmfsa.org | Press queries: press@fmfsa.org
    View All Articles

    RELATED ARTICLES

    WATCH OUR LATEST VIDEO

    Subscribe

    FUND FMF

    Help FMF to promote the rule of law, personal liberty, and economic freedom.

    Fund Freedom